Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus


Wine Down Wednesday 🍷 


All Bottles of Wine 20% off 

Wines by the Glass 50% off

Only Available Wednesdays 

Click Here for Beer Garden Band Schedule
  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • Antipasti & Insalata

    • Old School Chopped Salad

      $16

    • Caesar Salad

      Classic dressing, focaccia croutons, white anchovy

      $14

    • Baby Arugula & Watermelon

      Goat cheese, marcona almonds

      $14

    • Burrata Mozzarella

      Roasted asparagus, bottarga

      $16

    • 24 Month Aged Prosciutto Di Parma

      Seasonal melon, chestnut honey, fennel pollen

      $18

    • Hamachi Crudo

      Pineapple, jalapeno, seaweed, avocado, yuzu

      $14

    • General Tso Calamari

      Calabrian chilies. sesame seeds, scallion

      $16

    • Grilled Octopus

      Romesco. shaved fennel and citrus

      $24

    • Shishito Peppers

      Pickled mustard seed, bottarga

      $18

    • Short Rib Meatballs

      Creamy artisanal polenta, whipped ricotta

      $16

    • Cured Imported Meats & Cheeses

      $30

    Primi

    • Paccheri Bolognese

      Classic ragu of veal, beef, pork

      $32

    • Gnocchi Sorrentina

      Ricotta di Bufalo, San Marzano tomato, fresh basil, hand stretched mozzarella

      $30

    • Bucatini Vongole Amatriciana

      Manila clams, pancetta, tomato

      $34

    • Fusilli Lobster Vodka

      Spicy Tomato Vodka Crema

      $38

    • Vesuvio Papalina

      Prosciutto, peas, asparagus, light crema

      $28

    • Cavatelli

      Chicken sausage, broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomatoes, parmigiana

      $30

    • Black Spaghetti & Crab

      Colossal crab, grape tomato, corn, prosecco-saffron crema

      $36

    Secondi

    • Eggplant Parmesan Ala Siciliano

      Tomato sugo, mozzarella, side pasta

      $28

    • Lancaster County Organic Chicken Breast

      Escarole, gigante beans, sauce piccata

      $32

    • Faroe Island Salmon

      Fava beans, Jersey corn, summer squash, green garlic yogurt

      $36

    • Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

      Pesto risotto, Sicilian wine sauce

      $38

    • 12 oz. Filet Mignon

      Smoked eggplant puree, sun chokes, organic mushrooms

      $62

    • Berkshire Pork Chop & Peppers

      Broccoli rabe, sweet & hot peppers

      $38

    • 14 oz. Creekstone Farms NY Strip Steak

      Heirloom tomatoes, Italian chicories, gorgonzola fonduta, crispy onion rings

      $52

    • Grilled Branzino Filet

      Lemon potatoes, castelvetrano olives, salsa verde

      $38

    • Please restrict your dining time to 2 hours so we may accommodate all our guests

    Contorni

    All $14 each

    • Broccoli Rabe & Hot Cherry Peppers

      $14

    • Bloomsdale Spinach

      Sliced toasted garlic, extra virgin olive oil

      $14

    • Rosemary Fingerling Potatoes

      $14

    • Truffle Fries

      $14

  • Slide 1 of 15
  • Slide 2 of 15
  • Slide 3 of 15
  • Slide 4 of 15
  • Slide 5 of 15
  • Slide 6 of 15
  • Slide 7 of 15
  • Slide 8 of 15
  • Slide 9 of 15
  • Slide 10 of 15
  • Slide 11 of 15
  • Slide 12 of 15
  • Slide 13 of 15
  • Slide 14 of 15
  • Slide 15 of 15

    • Dessert Menu

    • Warm Chocolate Espresso Cake

      Hazelnut gelato, amarena cherries

      $12

    • Italian Cheesecake

      Fruit compote

      $10

    • Corn Panna Cotta

      Blueberry

      $12

    • Affogato

      Double espresso, vanilla gelato

      $8

    • Sicilian Cannoli

      Sheep's milk ricotta, candied fruit, chocolate chips

      $12

    • Orange Scented Olive Oil Cake

      Whipped mascarpone, sea salt

      $12

    Fortified And Dessert Wines

    These offerings are listed by the glass (3 oz.)

    • Fonseca 10 Yr Tawny

      Duoro, Portugal

      $8

    • Fonseca 20 Yr Tawny

      Duoro, Portugal

      $13

    • Quinta Do Crasto LBV

      Douro, Portugal, 2010

      $12

    • Churchill’s Quinta Da Gricha Vintage 2007

      Duoro, Portugal

      $26

    • Desi “Lily Hill Vineyard” Late Harvest Zinfandel

      Dry Creek Valley, California 2017

      $15

    • Le Ragose Recioto Della Valpolicella Classico

      Veneto, Italy, 2014

      $19

    • Terrassous Rivesaltes, Hors D’Age 6 Years

      Languedoc-Roussillon, France

      $8

    These Offerings Are Listed By The Glass (2 Oz.)

    • Broadbent 10 Yr, Sercial Madeira

      Madeira, Portugal

      $11

    • Broadbent 10 Yr Verdelho Madeira

      Madeira, Portugal

      $11

    • Broadbent 10 Yr Malmsey Madeira

      Madeira, Portugal

      $11

    • Vin Santo Di Montepulciano, Bindella “Dolce Sinfonia”

      Tuscany, Italy, 2011

      $13

    • Château Suduiraut Sauternes Premier Cru

      Bordeaux, France

      $18

    • Inniskillin Vidal Icewine

      Niagara Penisula, Canada 2017

      $26

    • Inniskillin Cabernet Franc Icewine

      Niagara Penisula, Canada 2017

      $43

    By The Glass White

    • Soave, La Formica

      Veneto, Italy, 2019

      $10

    • Sauvignon Blanc, Glazebrook

      Marlborough, New Zealand 2021

      $12

    • Pinot Grigio, Santi

      Valdadige, Italy, 2020

      $11

    • Riesling Steinbock

      Mosel, Germany, 2019

      $10

    • Chateau Peyrassol

      Provence, France, 2019

      $14

    • Bourgogne, J.J. Vincent

      Burgundy, France, 2019

      $16

    • Chardonnay, Banshee

      Sonoma Coast, California, 2018

      $14

    Sparkling

    • Prosecco, Lamberti

      Veneto, Italy NV

      $11

    • Brut, Collet

      Champagne, France, NV

      $19

    By The Glass Red

    • Chianti Classico Mannucci Droandi “Ceppeto”

      Tuscany, Italy, 2017

      $13

    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Route Stock, Napa Valley, California 2018

      $16

    • Pinot Noir

      Hinman Vineyards Willamette Valley, Oregon, 2017

      $13

    • Cotes du Rhone

      Chateau de Beaurenard Rhone, France, 2020

      $14

    • Nicodemi Montepulciano D’Abruzzo

      Abruzzo, Italy, 2018

      $11

    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Liberty School Reserve, Paso Robles, California, 2018

      $18

    House Cocktails

    • IL Ciccio

      Titos, lime, fresh basil

      $13

    • Guava Lamp

      Blanco Tequila, Jalapeno, Guava, Cointreau, Lime, Black Lava Salt

      $15

    • Pinky “In” The Brain

      Tito's Vodka, passionfruit, pineapple, lemon

      $14

    • Grotto Manhatten

      Bourbon, Amaro, Carpano Antica, Orange Bitters

      $16

    Seasonal Cocktails

    • Grey Gardens

      Grey Whale Gin, Cocchi Americano, Cucumber, Lime Cordial, Ginger Beer

      $15

    • Tropic Like It's Hot

      Gold Rum, Mint, Falernum, Pineapple, Lime, Ginger Beer

      $15

    • Pear Force One

      Vodka, Pear Puree, House Chamomile Syrup, Fresh Lemon

      $14

    Mocktails

    • Lavender Lemonade

      Fresh Lemon, House Lavender Infusion, Cane Sugar

      $9

    • Category 1

      Passionfruit, Fresh Lime, Pineapple, Grenadine

      $8

    Beer On Tap

    • Twin Lights 2nd Anniversary

      Imperial DIPA, 7.4%

      $9

    • Icarus Invincible Summer

      Pale Ale, Coconut 6.0%

      $9

    • Einstock

      White Ale 5.2%

      $9

    • Miller Lite

      American light lager 4.7%

      $6

    • Big Man's Brew

      Hazy Groove IPA 6.3%

      $8

    • Peroni

      European Pale Lager 5.1%

      $8

    • Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale

      Irish Red Ale 8.2%

      $8

    • Sullivan's Black Marble Stout

      Irish Extra Stout 5.1%

      $7

    Beer In Bottle/Cans

    • Coors Light

      $5

    • Blue Moon

      Belgian style wheat ale 5.4%

      $6

    • Heineken

      $6

    • Corona

      $6

    • Heineken Zero

      Non-alcoholic

      $4

    • Ross Brewing "It's a Mood"

      DDH Milkshake IPA with Cherries & Vanilla

      $8

    BLU Grotto Happy Hour

    5pm-9pm Wednesday & Thursday

    5pm-7pm Friday (not available certain Dates  (7/29, 8/19, 8/21, 8/28, 9/2, 9/9)

    4pm-9pm Sunday

    Available at the Bar & Taverna Booths only

    Drinks

    • Draft Beer

      $5

    • Well Drinks

      $7

    • House Martini

      $10

    • Red or White Wine

      $8

    Food

    • Lacquered Lollipop Lamb Chops

      Pineapple mostarda

      $16

    • Smoked Mozzarella Arancini

      Rice balls, nduja, pomodoro sauce

      $14

    • Short Rib Meatballs

      Creamy Polenta, Whipped Ricotta, Tomato

      $11

    • Shishito Peppers

      pickled mustard seeds, bottarga

      $12

    • Ricotta Crostini

      Truffle honey, hazelnuts, rosemary

      $12

    • Carciofi Fritti

      Fried baby artichokes, truffle aioli, lemon

      $14

    • Spiced Garlic Shrimp

      Smoked paprika, lemon

      $14

    • Tuna Tartare

      Capers, bottarga, lemon oil

      $16

    • Bowl of Chorizo & Clams

      Tons of garlic, white wine, crusty bread

      $18

    Beer Garden Menu

    • Pat Lafrieda Burger

      NY State White Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Brioche Bun

      $16

    • Chicken Wings Scarpariello

      Hot Cherry Pepper, Agrodolce

      $16

    • San Gennaro Style Sausage & Peppers

      Italian Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Italian Roll

      $14

    • House-Made Mozzarella Caprese

      Tomato, Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Balsamic Reduction

      $12

    Sushi Starters

    • Seaweed Salad

      $7

    • Edamame

      Ponzu Sauce, Sea Salt

      $8

    • Crab Salad

      Crab, Carrots, Cucumber, Spicy Mayo, Crunchy Onion

      $10

    • Black Pepper Tuna

      Pepper Tuna, Ponzu Sauce

      $18

    • Blu Grotto Avocado Boat

      Spicy Tuna, Spicy Mayo, Tobiko

      $16

    • Shrimp Tempura

      Shrimp Tempura, Sweet Chili Sauce

      $15

    • Yellowtail Crudo

      Ponzu Sauce, Jalapeño, Scallion, Tobiko

      $19

    • Sashimi

      $7

    • Nigiri

      $7

    Traditional Rolls

    • California Roll

      Crab, Cucumber, Avocado, Sesame Seed

      $10

    • Rainbow Roll

      Crab, Cucumber, Topped with Avocado, Tuna, Salmon

      $18

    • Spicy Tuna Maki

      Spicy Tuna, Cucumber, Spicy Mayo, Crunchy Onion, Sesame Seed

      $10

    • Veggie Maki

      Asparagus, Carrot, Cucumber, Avocado, Sesame Seed

      $8

    • Shrimp Tempura Maki

      Shrimp Tempura, Carrots, Avocado, Eel Sauce, Sesame Seed

      $14

    Specialty Maki

    • Blu Grotto Maki

      Shrimp Tempura, Topped with Avocado, Salmon, Tuna, Yellowtail, Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Cilantro, Tobiko

      $20

    • Pepper Tuna Dragon Maki

      Shrimp Tempura, Topped with Pepper Tuna, Eel Sauce

      $18

    • Crunchy Dragon Maki

      Crab, Cucumber, Topped with Avocado, Spicy Tuna

      $18

    • Super Salmon Maki

      Salmon, Cucumber, Topped with Avocado, Salmon, Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Crunchy Onion

      $18

    • Volcano Maki

      Crab, Cucumber, Topped with Avocado, Spicy Tuna, Jalapeño, Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Crunchy Onion

      $18

    • Garden State Maki

      Spicy Shrimp, Topped with Avocado, Tuna, Yellowtail, Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Scallion, Tobiko

      $18

    Poke Bowls

    All bowls are served with sushi rice, seaweed salad, crunchy onion

    • Blu Grotto Bowl

      Tuna, Salmon, Yellowtail, Cucumber, Avocado, Ginger, Ponzu, Scallion, Cilantro, Tobiko, Sesame Seed

      $22

    • Tuna Bowl

      Tuna, Avocado, Cucumber, Ginger, Ponzu Sauce, Cilantro, Tobiko

      $20

    • Spicy Salmon Bowl

      Salmon, Cucumber, Avocado, Ponzu Sauce, Cilantro, Tobiko

      $20

    • Super Vegetable Bowl

      Asparagus, Cucumber, Carrots, Avocado, Ginger, Ponzu Sauce, Cilantro

      $16

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!