Old School Chopped Salad

Everything but the kitchen sink, chianti vinaigrette (contains meat, cheese and nuts)

$16

Caesar Salad

Classic dressing, focaccia croutons, white anchovy

$14

Bibb Lettuce & Fennel

Pomegranate, gorgonzola, candied walnuts

$14

Burrata Mozzarella

Roasted beets, Sicilian pistachio

$16

Prosciutto di Parma & Melon

Roasted delicata squash, brown butter, sage

$16

Hamachi Crudo

Pickled grapes, marcona almonds, buttermilk, basil

$14

General Tso Calamari

Calabrian chilies. sesame seeds, scallion

$16

Polpo alla Luciana

Baby octopus ragu, San Marzano tomato, olives, country bread

$18

Shishito Peppers

Pickled mustard seed, bottarga

$18

Short Rib Meatballs

Creamy artisanal polenta, whipped ricotta

$16

Cured Imported Meats & Cheeses

$30

Paccheri Bolognese

Classic ragu of veal, beef, pork

$32

Rabbit Cacciatore

Ricotta gnocchi, porcini mushrooms, olives, tomatoes

$32

Malfadini Vongole

Manila clams, white wine, garlic, parsley, peperoncini

$32

Farfalle Tre Funghi

Organic mushrooms, smoked duck, braised radicchio

$32

Rigatoni Lobster Vodka

Spicy tomato vodka crema

$38

Fusilloni Norcina

Sweet sausage, smoked buffalo mozzarella, truffle crema

$30

Black Spaghetti Fra Diablo

Colossal crab, nduja calabrese, spicy pomodoro

$34

Eggplant Parmesan Ala Siciliano

Tomato sugo, mozzarella, side pasta

$28

Chicken Breast Scarpariello

Italian sausage, hot peppers, rosemary potatoes

$30

Faroe Island Salmon

Pancetta brussels sprouts, cauliflower puree

$36

Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

Pesto risotto, Sicilian wine sauce

$38

12 oz. Filet Mignon

Smoked mozzarella potato gratin, glazed baby carrots, brandy peppercorn

$64

Berkshire Pork Chop & Peppers

Broccoli rabe, sweet & hot peppers

$38

14 oz. Creekstone Farms NY Strip Steak Tagliata

Roasted broccolini, buttermilk onion rings, gorgonzola fonduta

$52

Grilled Branzino Filet

Lemon potatoes, castelvetrano olives, salsa verde

$38

Local Swordfish Livornese

San Marzano tomato, olives, capers, fregola

$34

Please restrict your dining time to 2 hours so we may accommodate all our guests

Broccoli Rabe & Hot Cherry Peppers

$14

Bloomsdale Spinach

Sliced toasted garlic, extra virgin olive oil

$14

Rosemary Fingerling Potatoes

$14

Truffle Fries

$14

Warm Chocolate Espresso Cake

Hazelnut gelato, amarena cherries

$12

Italian Cheesecake

Fruit compote

$10

Sicilian Pistachio Cake

Citrus Caramel, Crème Fraiche, Pistachio Gelato

$12

Affogato

Double espresso, vanilla gelato

$8

Sicilian Cannoli

Sheep's milk ricotta, candied fruit, chocolate chips

$12

Orange Scented Olive Oil Cake

Whipped mascarpone, sea salt

$12

Fonseca 10 Yr Tawny

Duoro, Portugal

$8

Fonseca 20 Yr Tawny

Duoro, Portugal

$13

Quinta Do Crasto LBV

Douro, Portugal, 2010

$12

Churchill’s Quinta Da Gricha Vintage 2007

Duoro, Portugal

$26

Desi “Lily Hill Vineyard” Late Harvest Zinfandel

Dry Creek Valley, California 2017

$15

Le Ragose Recioto Della Valpolicella Classico

Veneto, Italy, 2014

$19

Terrassous Rivesaltes, Hors D’Age 6 Years

Languedoc-Roussillon, France

$8

Broadbent 10 Yr, Sercial Madeira

Madeira, Portugal

$11

Broadbent 10 Yr Verdelho Madeira

Madeira, Portugal

$11

Broadbent 10 Yr Malmsey Madeira

Madeira, Portugal

$11

Vin Santo Di Montepulciano, Bindella “Dolce Sinfonia”

Tuscany, Italy, 2011

$13

Château Suduiraut Sauternes Premier Cru

Bordeaux, France

$18

Inniskillin Vidal Icewine

Niagara Penisula, Canada 2017

$26

Inniskillin Cabernet Franc Icewine

Niagara Penisula, Canada 2017

$43

Draft Beer

$5

Select Bottle/Can Beer

$4

Well Drinks

$7

Select Red or White Wine

$8

Select Cocktails

Vodka or Gin Martini, Manhattan, Cosmopolitan, Old Fashioned, Margarita, Moscow Mule

$10

Pinsa Romano

Roman Style Margherita Pizza, Hand Stretched Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil

$18

Lacquered Lollipop Lamb Chops

Pineapple mostarda

$18

Meatball Parm Hoagie

Sinatra sauce, hand stretched mozzarella

$14

Wagyu Blu Grotto Burger

Bacon & onion jam, white cheddar, fries, brioche

$26

Ricotta Crostini

Truffle honey, hazelnuts, rosemary

$12

Carciofi Fritti

Fried baby artichokes, truffle aioli, lemon

$16

Spiced Garlic Shrimp

Smoked paprika, lemon

$14

Truffle Brats

House fries, horseradish mustard, house pickles

$16

Bowl of Chorizo & Clams

Tons of garlic, white wine, crusty bread

$18

Black Magic

Blanco Tequila, Blackberry, Sage, Aperol, Lime, Black Lava Salt

$15

Pear Force One

Tasmanian Pure Vodka, Pear Puree, Cinnamon Syrup, Fresh Lemon

$14

Pinky “In” The Brain

Tasmanian Pure Vodka, Passionfruit, Pineapple, Fresh Juiced Lemon

$14

Grotto Manhatten

Asbury Park Double Barrel Bourbon, Amaro, Carpano Antica, Orange Bitters

$16

Sweater Weather

Red Wine, Apple Liqueur, Autumn Spices, Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice, Seasonal Fruit

$14

Copy Cat

Barr Hill TomCat Gin, Rosemary, Honey, Fresh Lemon, Prosecco

$15

Sunset Boulevardier

Angel's Envy Bourbon, Chili Infused Sweet Vermouth, Campari

$15

House Made Apple Ginger Shrub

Topped with Seltzer

$9

Category 1

Passionfruit, Fresh Lime, Pineapple, Grenadine

$8

Twin Lights Popamora Pilsner

German Style Pilsner 5.4%

$8

Icarus Invincible Summer

Pale Ale, Coconut 6.0%

$8

Einstock

White Ale 5.2%

$8

Miller Lite

American light lager 4.7%

$5

Delirium Deleria

Belgian Strong Pale Ale 8.5%

$10

Peroni

European Pale Lager 5.1%

$7

Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale

American Strong Ale 8.2%

$7

Sullivan's Black Marble Stout

Irish Extra Stout 5.1%

$7

Coors Light

$5

Blue Moon

Belgian style wheat ale 5.4%

$6

Heineken

$6

Corona

$6

Heineken

$6

PROSECCO, Lamberti

Veneto, Italy, N.V.

$11

$42

Champagne, Collet

Champagne, France, N.V.

$22

$86

Syrah/Grenache, Hecht & Bannier

Provence, France, 2021

$14

$54

Negroamaro, Kreos

Puglia, Italy, 2021

$12

$46

Moscato D’Asti, Alasia

Piedmont, Italy, 2021

$11

$42

Soave, Pieropan

Veneto, Italy, 2020

$12

$46

Sancerre, Pascal Jolivet

Loire, France, 2020

$22

$86

Sauvignon Blanc, Glazebrook

Marlborough, New Zealand, 2021

$12

$46

Pinot Grigio, Santi

Valdadige, Italy, 2022

$11

$42

Chardonnay, Banshee

Sonoma Coast, California, 2019

$14

$54

Chardonnay, JJ Vincent Bourgogne

Burgundy, France, 2020

$16

$62

Pinot Noir, Hinman Vineyard

Willamette Valley, Oregon, 2019

$13

$50

Pinot Noir, Elizabeth Chambers

Willamette Valley, Oregon, 2018

$22

$86

Zinfandel, Piluna Primitivo

Puglia, Italy, 2020

$9

$34

Côtes du Rhône, Domaine de Beaurenard

Rhône, France, 2020

$12

$46

Montepulciano, Barone Cornacchia

Abruzzo, Italy, 2019

$12

$46

Chianti Riserva, Mannucci Droandi Ceppeto

Tuscany, Italy, 2014

$16

$63

Cabernet Sauvignon, Liberty School Reserve

Paso Robles, California, 2020

$18

$70